Going Digital and On Demand – Part 2 Music

June 9, 2009

by — Posted in Family and Friends, Technology

Picture from here

A few months ago I lost all of my MP3’s that I had been accumulating for over 10 years.  It was a bad hard drive crash and over 200GB of music was lost in this tragedy.   One blessing of this is that we got to start from scratch.  Until a couple weeks I managed to keep putting off the long haul of going through hundreds of CDs to rerip them to MP3 so we can put them on our iPods and listen to our hearts content.

The problem with our previous collection is that there was no uniformity, the sources from the files were varied, the tags were a mess – so now we have a clean slate to work from.  Over the last two weeks I’ve been ripping CDs (and I’m amazed at how many “important” CDs we have lost).    I found one last night, so the ripping is not completely over – but on Friday night I managed to get through the bulk and any ones left are going to be onesy-twosy rips, which I can handle.  The new rule of the house is going to be, when a CD comes into the house it doesn’t get listened, it gets ripped and packed away.  An example of this is the new Green Day Album, I never listened to the physical CD at all, I did listen to it after I ripped it.

The problem on the outset was what size to rip them to.   Of course the discussion online focus on 192kbs for size up to 320 kbs for quality.   There is rampant discussions on whether someone can hear the difference of qualities so I did a test myself.   Between 192 kbs and 220 kbs I could tell a difference, so 192 kbs was out.   I then had Xie test between 220 kbs, 240 kbs, and 320 kbs.    She could tell the difference between 220 kbs and 240 kbs, but not 320.  So 240 kbs VBR was our baseline.

All of our MP3s now have proper tagging and album art embedded into the MP3, uniformity at last.   Now we have the other problem to go through.  What about non-CD media.   I’m still at a cross roads at that, I have cassette tapes (non-music and personal) that I want to save, plus we have a semi large (by today’s standards anyways) LP collection.   The LP’s I’ll probably borrow or buy CD versions of those to rip.   When I figure out how I want to do the cassettes I’ll let you know.

I have learned my lesson though, currently my MP3s are backed up on two different computers.  One is a “master” share and the other backup.   So I’m attempting to fight off a had drive dying again.

Leave a Reply